Superstar

Is New York Post Cartoon With Super-Obese Jessica Simpson Cruel or Comedy?

By: Marissa Brassfield - Published: • References: dailymail & nypost
Jessica Simpson's appearance at the KIIS FM Chili Cookoff was meant to be just another appearance for the pop/country crooner. Instead, it's sparked an insidious weight war between A-listers and the media, with Simpson stuck in the middle.

Jessica Simpson's sister, Ashlee, stuck up for her sister, as did Miley Cyrus, Justin Gaston, Kim Kardashian, and Simpson's former personal trainer. They're pitted against headlines from major newspapers and media outlets like "Jessica Simpson's a bigger star than ever as she shows off her new curvier figure," "Kim Kardashian defends chubby Jessica, " "Give Celebs a Fat Chance," and "Jessica Simpson is Getting Fat!"

To top it all off, the New York Post ran a cartoon on January 28 that depicted an obese Jessica Simpson telling Tony Romo that she'd left him for McDonald's. While no one can argue that Simpson is the tiny, svelte star she was in months past, she's not big by any means. Is such gratuitous exaggeration comedy, or just plain cruel? Stats for Viral Celeb Weight Wars Trending: Older & Buzzing
Traction: 26,122 clicks in 307 w
Interest: > 3 minutes
Concept: Viral Celeb Weight Wars
Related: 65 examples / 50 photos
Segment: Neutral, 18-35
Comparison Set: 24 similar articles, including: 40 controversial views on body image, 25 controversial photoshopped celebs, and 12 high-waisted fashions.